Which influencers bring new followers to a brand’s account at a product launch? What a Journal of Business Research study found
When a big video game comes out, its official account wants the fans that gamers and commentators already have. More than two million launch tweets show which kind of influencer actually sends their audience across, and which common assumptions about picking creators did not hold up.
Benevento et al. follow 197 influencers through three game launches on Twitter: those drawing more likes and sitting at the hub of the chatter moved more fans.
Marketing in 3 · 2024 in research · No. 51 · Paper published 7 December 2024
Gamers already have an audience. The ones whose fans react the most are the ones who bring them along to a launch. Photo: Sean Do on Unsplash.
The short answer
The ones whose audiences react, and who sit at the centre of the conversation. Across three big video game launches on Twitter, 197 influencers were tracked from 20 days before release to a month after. Those whose posts drew more likes and retweets for the size of their audience, and who had more direct links in the launch chatter, saw more of their followers move to the game's official account. Sheer follower count made no difference.
Evidence level
★★★One study
★★★Several studies
★★★Meta-analysis
Key takeaways
On average, 0.75% of an influencer's followers, about one person in 130, went on to follow the game's own account during the launch window.
About half of what these influencers posted (50%) was entertainment and one post in seven (14%) was informative, yet neither mix changed how many followers crossed over.
Influencers who follow a great many accounts did worse: the average influencer followed 1,418 accounts, and a longer list went with a smaller share of fans moving across.
Together, the factors in the model explained 44% of the differences between influencers, and the result survived three alternative ways of running the numbers.
What the researchers did
Elisabetta Benevento, Davide Aloini and Davide Bellino of the University of Pisa, with Paolo Roma of the University
of Palermo, looked at a moment every launch team knows. A new product goes on sale, creators start talking about it,
and the brand hopes some of their audience will follow its own account too. The team asked which creators actually
make that happen.
Their setting was video games, where players take their cues from each other and from social media when choosing what to try,
and where every big title gets its own official account and hashtag. They followed three releases on Twitter (now X):
Final Fantasy VII Remake in April 2020, then Elden Ring and God of War Ragnarök in 2022. Each sold at least five
million copies within about three months.
From the tweets posted before each release, they drew a map of who retweeted whom. They then picked out individual
accounts that ranked near the very top on three counts at once: followers, direct links in that map, and how often
they sat on the paths connecting other users. News outlets and company accounts were left out. They kept collecting
tweets every day and regularly refreshed the follower lists of every influencer and of the game's official account,
so they could see which of an influencer's followers began following the game once the influencer had posted about it.
Platform
Twitter (now X), with tweets collected daily under each game's official hashtag
Launches
Final Fantasy VII Remake (April 2020), Elden Ring (February 2022), God of War Ragnarök (November 2022)
Window
From 20 days before each release to one month after
Tweets
Over two million in all: more than 800,000, more than a million and about 450,000, in the order above
Influencers
197 accounts (40, 59 and 98 per game), each in the top 5% on followers and on both network measures
Outcome
Share of each influencer's followers who began following the game's official account after the influencer's first post about it
Analysis
Regression with robust errors, repeated with two other model types and on a subsample of 157 with location added
What moved followers, and what did not
The team tested six expectations and three held. The first was about response. They measured it as the likes and
retweets an influencer's posts drew, per post and relative to audience size, and the higher it was, the more of their
followers ended up following the game too. The second was a closely related popularity score: total likes divided by
followers. The third was position. Influencers with more direct retweet links in the launch conversation, the hubs,
moved more of their audience.
Several things you might expect to matter did not. Follower count had no measurable link with the share who crossed
over. Neither did the influencer's gender. Two controls did show up. Influencers who posted videos of themselves
playing the game, a sign they were gamers rather than general commentators, moved more fans. And the game itself
counted: after allowing for everything else, the other two games converted less well than Elden Ring.
How many of an influencer's followers also began following the official game account, average per influencer (%)
How many of an influencer's followers also began following the official game account, average per influencer (%)
Group
Value (%)
Elden Ring (59)
1.26
Final Fantasy VII Remake (40)
0.82
God of War Ragnarök (98)
0.43
All 197 influencers
0.75
Descriptive statistics per game (number of influencers in brackets), measured over each game's launch window on Twitter. Raw averages, before the model's controls.
Why a hub beats a bridge
Network researchers describe two kinds of well-placed account. A hub has lots of direct ties: many people retweet it
and it retweets many in return. A bridge sits between groups that would otherwise not meet, so information has to
pass through it. The authors noticed that many of the influencers here scored higher as bridges than as hubs, and
read it as a sign that they saw their job as passing news along between circles of fans.
That role did not translate into new followers for the game. Being a bridge showed no link with crossover in any of
the models. The authors explain it this way: a hub talks to a large, engaged group every day, learns what that group
wants and makes posts that fit, so a recommendation from a hub lands with people who already trust it.
What they posted mattered less than how people reacted
The team read every post the 197 influencers wrote and sorted it by hand. Release dates, countdowns, clarifications
and pre-order instructions counted as informative. Videos, pictures, sound clips, GIFs and links shared for fun
counted as entertainment. A post could be both, or neither.
They had expected useful information to win followers for the game and pure entertainment to distract from it.
Neither happened. Once reactions and network position were in the model, content type had no bearing on crossover.
The authors think people simply follow the crowd: a post that many others have liked looks trustworthy
and current, and users like to join conversations that are already busy. That runs against earlier studies that put
content first.
What the influencers posted: average share of their launch posts, by game (%)
What the influencers posted: average share of their launch posts, by game (%)
Group
Value (%)
Final Fantasy VII Remake, entertainment
53.9
Elden Ring, entertainment
45.4
God of War Ragnarök, entertainment
52.2
Final Fantasy VII Remake, informative
18.7
Elden Ring, informative
6.4
God of War Ragnarök, informative
17.6
All posts by the 197 influencers, sorted by hand. A post could count as both or neither, so the shares do not add up to 100. Neither share predicted followers crossing over.
Picking launch partners on this evidence
The authors suggest that brands judge possible partners on three things before signing: how central they are in
the conversation, how strongly their audience responds, and how many likes their posts collect. All three were built
here from public posts and follower lists. They also tell creators to reply to comments, start conversations and invite reactions.
A word of warning, which comes from us and not from the paper. The response measure here was built from likes and retweets on the
influencer's posts, not from replies the influencer wrote, so the paper shows that lively audiences cross over, not
that answering fans makes them do so. It is a reasonable bet that the two go together, but this research does not
settle it.
Marketing in 3 steps
Ready. Set. Market.
1
ReadyDecide and prepare
Score creators on how their fans react. Six weeks before launch, write down 20 creators who already post about your category. Open each one's ten most recent posts and total the likes and reposts. Split that total over their number of followers, then put the creators in order, highest score first.
Find who sits at the centre. Search your category's main hashtags for the past month. Note which accounts others repost and reply to again and again. Move those creators up your list, and drop anyone who follows thousands of accounts in what looks like a follow-back habit.
2
SetBuild it
Choose people who use the product. Favour creators who show themselves using products like yours on camera. Send them early access a few weeks before release so they have real footage, not just a press kit.
Plan posts across the whole launch window. Ask creators to start posting about three weeks before release and to keep going for a month after it. Give them your official handle and hashtag to include in every post.
3
MarketLaunch and measure
Count who crosses over. Once a week, export your account's new followers and check how many also follow each creator. Some social listening tools can do this match for you.
Rehire on crossover. After the first month, rank creators by how many of their followers now follow you. Keep the top third for the next launch and replace the bottom third.
Found this useful?
Marketing in 3 is free and ad-free, with new issues every Monday and Thursday. A coffee keeps it that way.
Big gaps between creators. Some influencers moved nobody at all, while the best single result was a little over 5% of an audience. A few strong partners can matter more than a long roster.
Mid-sized accounts did the work. The influencers here averaged about 11,100 followers, the scale often called micro-influencers, not celebrity accounts with millions.
A short window. The authors chose their 20-days-before, one-month-after period because chatter around a new game is thin before it and fades soon after. Spend accordingly.
Competition for the best-placed creators. The paper quotes an industry report that expected influencer marketing to reach about $21.1 billion in 2023, with more than three brands in four holding a dedicated budget. Expect the creators at the centre of a launch conversation to be in demand.
Where it does not work
Linked, not proven. Nobody was assigned to post or not to post. The measure counts every follower of an influencer who later followed the game, whether or not that influencer's post was the reason.
Partners or simply fans? Influencers were chosen by their prominence in the hashtag conversation. The article never states whether any of them had a deal with a publisher.
Only existing followers. People who found the game's account through a viral retweet, without following the influencer, were not counted.
One platform, one industry, three blockbusters. Twitter's limits on bulk downloads kept the number of influencers modest. Instagram, YouTube, TikTok and other industries are still to be tested.
Questions marketers ask
Do influencers with more followers bring more followers to a brand?
Not in this research. Across three game launches, the size of an influencer's audience showed no measurable link with how many of those fans later followed the official game account. How strongly the audience responded, and how central the influencer was, mattered instead (Benevento et al., 2025).
What is a social hub in influencer marketing?
An account with many direct connections in a conversation. In this research, that meant the count of retweet links running to and from the influencer around a launch. It differs from a bridge, an account that links groups which would otherwise not meet.
Should launch influencers post information or entertainment?
On this evidence the mix did not matter. Posts sorted as informative (dates, countdowns, pre-order details) and posts sorted as entertainment (clips, images, GIFs) showed no link with followers crossing over once audience response was taken into account.
How can you tell whether an influencer grows a brand's following?
Compare follower lists over time. Take the influencer's followers who did not follow the brand when the campaign started, count how many follow it once the influencer has started posting about it, and divide by the influencer's average audience.
Why would following lots of accounts hurt an influencer?
The authors suggest audiences may take it as spam: an account that follows thousands of strangers, hoping they will follow back. That sits badly with the idea of a trusted voice.
Three experiments look at what happens when some customers get hold of something desirable and others feel unfairly shut out. A spiteful kind of envy is what turns that sense of injustice into a wish to get even. People hit back harder when they can stay anonymous and nobody will think worse of them for it. Exclusive drops and invite-only offers win attention, so expect any backlash where people can post without a name, such as anonymous reviews and forums.
Journal of Research in Interactive Marketing · 2025
This study asks which features of short videos lead viewers to contribute something back on the platform, using structural equation models and a fuzzy-set comparison of which combinations of features go together. Original videos and videos that felt relevant both drew more from viewers, partly because relevant clips felt grounded and both kinds left people inspired. Fun did not carry the effect. If your clips are not getting much back, freshness and closeness to viewers' lives may matter more than another joke.
Source
Benevento, E., Aloini, D., Roma, P., & Bellino, D. (2025). The impact of influencers on brand social network growth: Insights from new product launch events on Twitter. Journal of Business Research, 189, 115123. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.jbusres.2024.115123
This brief is written for practitioners from the published article. Open access (CC BY 4.0): free to read at the publisher. Numbers are as reported by the authors; read the article for full methods.
A meta-analysis of 210 experiments finds virtual influencers win on novelty, lose on credibility, and that how human they look decides which one matters.
Bruno Schivinski is Associate Professor of Marketing at Gdańsk University of Technology. He studies how consumers engage with brands in digital and social media.