Do emojis make reviews and brand posts more persuasive? What a Journal of the Academy of Marketing Science study found
Ten studies show that where a face emoji sits decides whether it helps. Placed after the word it echoes, it made reviews, posts and ads more persuasive. Dropped in where the word should be, it left readers guessing.
Maiberger et al. find a face emoji that repeats a word gives reviews, tweets and Facebook ads more pull, while one that replaces the word adds nothing.
Marketing in 3 · 2023 in research · No. 10 · Paper published 27 March 2023
Even a face this expressive reads more clearly with a word beside it. Photo: John Cardamone on Unsplash.
The short answer
Yes, when the emoji repeats a word rather than replacing it. Across ten studies, a face placed after the praise it echoed nudged people to choose, like, share and click. In a lab test, 82% picked a reviewed lemonade when the post said "really delicious" and added a face, against 54% for words alone. A face standing in for the word made the message vaguer and gained nothing overall.
Evidence level
★★★One study
★★★Several studies
★★★Meta-analysis
Key takeaways
A Facebook ad that repeated its key word with a face cost 0.55 euros per click, against 0.73 euros for the words-only version.
Status updates with a laughing face after "so funny" collected roughly twice the likes in 24 hours of the words-only posts (6.15 against 3.02).
A face in place of "really love" lifted intention to try a juice from 3.82 to 4.97 out of 7, but only when the review described the taste first.
Told about a deal by a close friend whose post used a face instead of praise, people wanted to tell about 5.5 others, against 3.6 for words; from an acquaintance, the face changed nothing.
What the researchers did
Tobias Maiberger, David Schindler and Nicole Koschate-Fischer
of Friedrich-Alexander-Universität Erlangen-Nürnberg, with Maiberger also at Darmstadt University of Applied Sciences,
looked at a habit almost everyone online shares: adding a little face to a message. Their question was whether it
matters how the face is used. An emoji can take the place of a word ("This lemonade is really" and then a face), or it can
follow the word and say it again ("really delicious" and then the face).
They ran ten studies, six main ones and four shorter follow-ups. Most used fictitious
or little-known brands, so no one came with views on them already. Three looked at behaviour outside the lab: likes on real
Facebook posts, reactions to brand tweets and clicks on a paid Facebook ad.
Alongside each outcome, most experiments measured two reactions. One was how fired up the message made readers feel,
which the authors call emotional arousal. The other was how unsure readers were about what the writer meant, called
perceived ambiguity.
Studies
Ten: six main studies plus four follow-ups detailed in a web appendix
People
College students, online panel members (MTurk, Clickworker, Prolific) and real Facebook users
Field data
Likes on participants' own Facebook posts, a sample of brand tweets and a paid Facebook ad test
What changed
Words only, a face emoji in place of the key word, or the same face placed after it
Measured
Product choice, likes, retweets, intention to try, deal sharing and ad clicks, plus arousal and ambiguity
Two things a face does at once
The team draws on a theory from psychology that treats emotions as social information. Seeing someone's expression
does two things. It passes on some of their feeling, and it tells us something about what they think. A face emoji,
the authors argue, works the same way in text.
The first effect should always help, because a face adds energy that plain words lack. The second can go either way.
Face emojis are slippery: according to Emojipedia, the average one carries more than four meanings, some of them
opposites. The slightly smiling face can mean fine or friendly, but also passive-aggressive or ironic. Standing alone,
it leaves readers to guess. Placed after a word, it has that word to pin down its meaning, and then it adds colour.
This is a common situation, not a niche one. In an initial scan of 10,000 posts made to the Facebook pages of ten
well-known brands, about one post in four contained a face emoji, and 55.1% of those faces stood in for a word rather
than repeating one.
The lemonade test
The first study was run in a lab. Of 132 students, 126 passed the attention checks. Each saw a mock Facebook post
praising an unknown lemonade, with the face savouring food emoji, then picked one of three brands on the promise of a
free sample.
Both emoji versions lifted arousal by about one point, out of a possible seven. Ambiguity split. With the emoji in
place of "delicious", readers were less sure what the writer meant than with words alone. With the emoji after the
word, they were more sure. In the replacing version the two effects offset each other: 56% chose the reviewed lemonade, no
real gain on words alone. Repeating the word is what moved choice.
Two follow-ups backed this up. One, with 165 online participants and a Bluetooth speaker, ruled out the idea that
repeating simply adds emphasis or makes the message easier to process. The other, with 145 students and a local
restaurant, found the result held for a negative emoji too.
Lemonade post: how fired up and how unsure readers felt (1 to 7 scale)
Lemonade post: how fired up and how unsure readers felt (1 to 7 scale)
Group
Value ()
Arousal, words only
4.85
Arousal, emoji replaces word
5.78
Arousal, emoji repeats word
5.85
Ambiguity, words only
2.08
Ambiguity, emoji replaces word
2.83
Ambiguity, emoji repeats word
1.39
Study 1, lab experiment with 126 students; group means as reported in the text and Figure 2. Lower ambiguity means readers were surer of the writer's meaning.
Likes on real feeds
To see whether real friends respond like this, the team recruited 118 Facebook users through MTurk who posted status
updates weekly or more often. Each posted a set status update about a funny Netflix show they had just watched, with "so funny" written
out, replaced by the face with tears of joy, or followed by it. After 24 hours they reported their likes, backed by a
screenshot. Across all posts the average was 4.16 likes. The replacing version did no better than words alone; the
repeating version is the one that pulled ahead.
The brand side came from Twitter. The team collected 2,137 English-language tweets posted by ten well-known brands
(Amazon, BMW, Lego, Mercedes Benz, Nescafé, Pepsi, Spotify, Starbucks, Toyota and YouTube) between September 2021 and
March 2022. Three coders, unaware of the study's aim, sorted every face emoji by its job. With tone, emotional words, other
emojis, length, links, media, hashtags, follower counts and age of the tweet held constant, tweets with repeating faces
attracted more likes and retweets. Tweets with replacing faces showed no significant link to either. These are observational
data, so they show an association rather than proof of cause.
A preregistered follow-up with 245 online participants and a made-up brand's tweet about a travel destination found the arousal and
ambiguity effects at work in brand messages as well.
Clicks on a paid ad
The last study put money behind the idea. The team created a fictitious headphone brand and ran three Facebook ads
with the line "Our new headphones now help you fall asleep. This is guaranteed fun." In one version "fun" was written
out, in one the face with tongue replaced it, and in one the face followed it. Each version had a budget of about 60
euros, and 7,948 Facebook users saw one of the three. The test was preregistered.
Click-through rates told the story seen in the lab. The replacing ad was not reliably better than words alone, but the
repeating ad was. By our arithmetic, its click rate was half as high again as that of the words-only ad, while the
authors report a saving per click of more than 20%.
Click-through rate of a Facebook ad, by emoji use
Click-through rate of a Facebook ad, by emoji use
Group
Value (%)
Words only
3.0
Emoji replaces "fun"
3.5
Emoji repeats "fun"
4.5
Study 6, preregistered field test of three Facebook ads for a fictitious headphone brand. Only the repeating version differed significantly from words only.
When a face can stand in for the word
A lone emoji is not always a problem. The authors expected readers to work out its meaning when they have
something else to go on, and tested two such cases.
The first was the text around it. In one test, 157 Clickworker panel members read a post about a new juice. The short
version just said the reviewer loved it; the rich version first said it had a great taste and was refreshing and not too
sweet. The heart-eyes face replaced "really love". After the richer text, the emoji made the review less ambiguous. In
the bare version it made it more ambiguous.
The second was the relationship. Another 191 students wrote down the name of either a close friend or a casual
acquaintance and imagined that person had posted about an e-reader on sale at 25% off, calling it "really awesome" or
"really" plus a face. People seem to learn a friend's emoji habits: from a close friend the lone face reduced ambiguity,
from an acquaintance it raised it. A follow-up with Generation Z adults on Prolific found the friend effect whether the
friend belonged to their own generation or another.
In both tests the energy boost from the face showed up regardless of the condition. What shifted was whether the face
cleared up the message or clouded it.
The authors' advice
For social listening, they suggest flagging reviews and comments in which a face repeats the words, since those are
the ones most likely to sway other shoppers. That includes negative comments, which they single out as worth a reply. Platforms
that rank the "most relevant" posts could also weigh the emoji's job and the context around it.
For reviews, they warn against prompts such as "Using an emoji, tell us what you think", because the answers come back
vague. They propose writing guidelines with model reviews, and a pop-up translation of each emoji when users hover over
it or press and hold it. They are also wary of keyboard features that swap words for emojis automatically in
conversations with brands.
For brand posts, ads and chatbots, they favour faces that repeat the words. Where a brand wants a face to stand alone,
they suggest richer copy around it and the same few emojis used consistently, so followers learn the brand's style much
as friends learn each other's.
Marketing in 3 steps
Ready. Set. Market.
1
ReadyDecide and prepare
Sort your emojis by job. Go through your last 20 social posts and ads. Mark each face emoji: does it repeat a word right next to it, or does it take the place of one? Count how many stand alone.
Pick a short list of faces. Choose four or five face emojis for your brand. Ask five customers what each one means and drop any face that gets two different answers. Use the same faces every time.
2
SetBuild it
Say it, then show it. Write the feeling in words and put the face straight after it: "really tasty" followed by the face, rather than the face alone. Keep to one face per sentence. Add the same rule to your chatbot and reply templates.
Give a lone face some context. When a face has to replace a word, as in a short headline, put two or three concrete sentences before it about taste, use or price. A bare one-liner ending in a face leaves people guessing.
3
MarketLaunch and measure
Test it on a paid post. Run the same ad twice on an equal budget: once with words only, once with words plus a matching face. After seven days, compare clicks per 1,000 views and the cost per click.
Ask for words in reviews. Never ask customers to rate you with an emoji alone. Ask for one sentence about what they liked and invite a face at the end. Feature the reviews that pair the two.
Found this useful?
Marketing in 3 is free and ad-free, with new issues every Monday and Thursday. A coffee keeps it that way.
A lift on a small base. Even the best ad drew fewer than five clicks per hundred views, so expect gains at the margins of a campaign rather than a new channel.
Lone faces rarely backfire outright. Used in place of a word, an emoji mostly did no worse than words, because its energy and its vagueness pulled in opposite directions.
Regulars read you better. The authors expect followers who know a brand's emoji habits to read its lone faces more accurately, which is why they advise a consistent set of faces.
Sharper social listening. Sorting reviews by whether the face repeats the words should, on the authors' reading, help pick out the posts that move other shoppers.
Where it does not work
Invented brands, one product each. Most tests used a made-up or little-known brand and a single product, from lemonade to headphones.
One face at a time. Each test message carried a single face emoji. Strings of emojis, object emojis and how many faces become too many were not tested.
Brands already known for emojis. The tweet analysis covered ten brands people link with emoji use, and it is observational. Brands for which emojis would look out of place may see a different response.
A small ad test. The paid test ran one ad per version, for one product, on a modest budget, and it counted clicks, not sales.
Samples and product types. Participants were students and online panel members, and whether emojis work differently for practical products than for fun ones is still open.
Questions marketers ask
Do emojis make online reviews more persuasive?
They can. A face emoji that backs up a word sitting right before it made reviews and posts more persuasive in a series of ten studies, while one used in place of the word made no overall difference on average (Maiberger et al., 2024).
Should brands use emojis in social media ads?
On this evidence, yes, if the face backs up a word in the copy. In a paid Facebook test that version earned more clicks, and cheaper ones, than the same ad without an emoji. Swapping the key word for a face did not reliably help.
Why can an emoji on its own confuse people?
Most face emojis have several possible readings. Without a word next to it, a reader has to guess whether a smile means delight, politeness or irony, and that doubt weakens the message.
When is it fine for an emoji to replace a word?
When the reader has other clues. A lone face worked when the review gave concrete detail before it, and when the message came from a close friend rather than an acquaintance.
Do emojis matter in negative reviews?
Yes. A follow-up using a negative face emoji found the same split between replacing and repeating. The authors see complaints where the face echoes the words as the ones most worth a reply.
Not every review moves a new product. Mining reviews on the Chinese retail platform JD.com with a topic model, the researchers sorted what shoppers wrote about into product quality and supporting services, then used panel data to relate review activity to how new products spread. Reviews about quality carried more weight than reviews about service. Some combinations surprised: a large volume of reviews with a positive emotional tone did not help a launch spread as expected. Before celebrating a pile of glowing reviews, read what they are actually about.
When something goes wrong in a live-stream shopping session, how the seller handles the complaint shapes whether the customer keeps taking part. With data gathered online and offline and a structural equation model, the authors found that replies in a conversational, human voice, longer replies and a sense of fair treatment all built swift guanxi, a quickly formed personal bond with the seller, which in turn kept customers engaged. One factor they call complaint publicization worked against continued participation. A good reply to a complaint goes well beyond the apology.
Source
Maiberger, T., Schindler, D., & Koschate-Fischer, N. (2024). Let’s face it: When and how facial emojis increase the persuasiveness of electronic word of mouth. Journal of the Academy of Marketing Science, 52(1), 119-139. https://doi.org/10.1007/s11747-023-00932-8
This brief is written for practitioners from the published article. Open access (CC BY 4.0): free to read at the publisher. Numbers are as reported by the authors; read the article for full methods.
Handing customers a ready-made post lifted sharing from 0.4% to 2.1% in a real gym campaign, and, less visibly, stopped unhappy customers posting at all. How to use it, and where it gets uncomfortable.
In a field test, a meme ad doubled click-through (1.40% against 0.65%) and raised ROAS from 1.14 to 1.52. Memes work only when mature and for mainstream products.
Schreiner et al. find fan posts on X mattered more for US opening weekends than searches or trailer comments; studio posts fed that talk, ads did not.
Bruno Schivinski is Associate Professor of Marketing at Gdańsk University of Technology. He studies how consumers engage with brands in digital and social media.