Skip to main content

Do larger-sized shoppers give online fashion stores better ratings? What a European Journal of Marketing study found

Women in larger sizes who fear weight-based judgement feel grateful to the online stores that dress them, and grateful shoppers hand out more stars. Three online studies, plus sales records from a big marketplace, follow that chain from feeling to rating to sales.

O’Rourke et al. find larger-sized women who fear weight stigma feel more grateful to online fashion stores, and that gratitude goes with higher star ratings.
Date

7 November 2026

Marketing in 3 · 2025 in research · No. 45 · Paper published 10 November 2025

T-shirts hang in a tight row on black hangers, white and cream at the front, then red, black, mustard yellow, burgundy and tan, with darker shirts fading out of focus
Black or a colour? The choice turned out to matter for how some shoppers felt about the store. Photo: Parker Burchfield on Unsplash.

The short answer

Some do, and gratitude appears to be the link. In an online study with 393 US women, those who wore larger sizes and worried that others judge them by their weight felt more grateful to a clothing seller, and grateful shoppers gave it more stars. Women without that worry showed no such pattern. Across 6.5 million sales of summer clothes on a large marketplace, better-rated sellers also sold more, though only modestly.

Evidence level
  1. One study
  2. Several studies
  3. Meta-analysis

Key takeaways

  • Among women in larger sizes, gratitude to the seller was about 3.8 out of 5 when worry about weight stigma was high, against about 3.1 when it was low.
  • The link between size and gratitude only appeared once worry about weight stigma reached 3.25 out of 7, a level that 62% of the women met or passed.
  • When women could pick from four colours, 57% to 58% chose black, yet black went with more gratitude for larger sizes in only two of three studies.
  • Being able to find one's size did not explain the gratitude, and a range of 64 designs worked no better than one of 4.

What the researchers did

Anne-Maree O’Rourke from The University of Queensland, Hiba Khan from Bond University, and Frank Mathmann and Shasha Wang from Queensland University of Technology, all in Australia, began with a well-known pattern. Many larger-sized women prefer to buy clothes online, partly to avoid fitting rooms, unhelpful staff and stores that tuck bigger sizes away. Far less is known about how these shoppers feel once they are on a retailer's site, and whether those feelings reach the seller's ratings.

The team's answer was gratitude. As they saw it, stocking larger sizes costs a seller more fabric and effort, while shopping online spares these customers some of the judgement they meet in person. That mix can leave shoppers thankful, and thankful people like to give something back.

Three online studies put women in front of an invented store, My Clothing Shop, offering one T-shirt in 14 sizes from 3XS to 8XL, with the chance to bid on it as an entry into a cash prize draw. Women then said how grateful, thankful and appreciative they felt towards the store. Their body size came from the clothing size they usually wear or, in one study, from the height and weight they reported. A fourth study turned to real sales records.

Participants
886 women recruited on Prolific: 313 in the UK, then 180 and 393 in the US
The store
An invented online seller offering a single T-shirt in every size from 3XS to 8XL
What changed
T-shirt colour, assigned in the first study and chosen by the women in the next two
Measured
Gratitude towards the store (1 to 5), worry about weight stigma (1 to 7) and, in the third study, a star rating
Field data
Seller ratings and sales for 1,491 summer clothing products on Wish.com
Design note
Body size cannot be assigned at random, so every link with size is an association

Worry about being judged makes the difference

The clearest result concerns weight stigma: the fear that other people will judge you, reject you or withhold respect on account of your weight.

The second study measured body size by body mass index. A higher index went with more gratitude only for women who felt this fear at a middle or high level. At a low level there was no link at all. The third study, with T-shirt size in place of body mass index, found the same thing. Among women who worried little, size did not change how grateful they felt. Among those with average or strong worry, larger sizes went with more gratitude, and the pattern was strongest among the most worried.

The authors think online shopping matters most to the women who most fear being judged in a store. The first study supports part of that story: women in bigger sizes reported more shame about shopping for clothes in person.

Gratitude to the online store, by T-shirt size and worry about weight stigma (1 to 5 scale)
Gratitude to the online store, by T-shirt size and worry about weight stigma (1 to 5 scale)12345Small sizes, low stigma worry: 3.33 Small sizes, low stigma worry3.33Small sizes, high stigma worry: 3.40 Small sizes, high stigma worry3.40Large sizes, low stigma worry: 3.13 Large sizes, low stigma worry3.13Large sizes, high stigma worry: 3.79 Large sizes, high stigma worry3.79
Gratitude to the online store, by T-shirt size and worry about weight stigma (1 to 5 scale)
Group Value ()
Small sizes, low stigma worry 3.33
Small sizes, high stigma worry 3.4
Large sizes, low stigma worry 3.13
Large sizes, high stigma worry 3.79

Study 3, 393 US women; values read from the published figure. Worry about weight stigma made a difference mainly for women in larger sizes.

Black helped, though not every time

Colour was the second factor. Black has a reputation for slimming and for letting the wearer blend in, so the team expected it to protect the comfort of shopping from home.

In the first study, colour was handed out at random. Among larger-sized women, those shown the black T-shirt reported more gratitude than those shown white, blue, green, yellow or grey. Among women in smaller sizes, black did slightly worse than the colours. In the second study women picked their own colour, and the pattern for black held.

The third study broke the run. There, the colour a woman chose did not alter the link between her size and her gratitude, even though black was again the most popular pick.

Gratitude to the online store, by T-shirt colour and size (1 to 5 scale)
Gratitude to the online store, by T-shirt colour and size (1 to 5 scale)12345Small sizes, coloured T-shirt: 2.79 Small sizes, coloured T-shirt2.79Small sizes, black T-shirt: 2.68 Small sizes, black T-shirt2.68Large sizes, coloured T-shirt: 2.88 Large sizes, coloured T-shirt2.88Large sizes, black T-shirt: 3.13 Large sizes, black T-shirt3.13
Gratitude to the online store, by T-shirt colour and size (1 to 5 scale)
Group Value ()
Small sizes, coloured T-shirt 2.79
Small sizes, black T-shirt 2.68
Large sizes, coloured T-shirt 2.88
Large sizes, black T-shirt 3.13

Study 1, 313 UK women, colour assigned at random (coloured means white, blue, green, yellow or grey); values read from the published figure.

Having your size was not the point

Could the gratitude simply be relief at finding something that fits? The team checked twice. In the first study they asked how much women expect to find their size when shopping for clothes online. That expectation had no bearing on gratitude, and the colour pattern survived with it taken into account. In the third study, half the women saw a store with a large range of designs and half a store with a small one. The size of the range changed nothing.

The authors put the gratitude down to how safe the online store feels, rather than to choice. Feeling safe was never measured, though, so this part rests on their interpretation.

From stars to sales

In the third study, women also gave My Clothing Shop a rating from one to five stars, and the average came to just over four. Gratitude did the connecting: once it was accounted for, body size and the rating were no longer linked. The route from size through gratitude to stars ran only for women with at least average worry about weight stigma.

The fourth study used records from a large online marketplace where third-party sellers are rated by buyers. Products from better-rated sellers sold more, a modest association with a correlation of 0.12. Products in larger sizes carried slightly higher seller ratings and also sold more, partly through those ratings. The pattern held when the team kept only products made for women. These are associations in real data. By the authors' own account, they cannot prove that ratings cause sales.

Marketing in 3 steps

Ready. Set. Market.

ReadyDecide and prepare
  • Audit your size range. List the sizes on offer for your 20 best-selling styles. Where a style stops at XL, plan two or three larger sizes for the next order.
  • Keep black in every size. For each style sold in extended sizes, offer black alongside the colours. Check stock weekly so black never runs out in the largest sizes first.
SetBuild it
  • Put every size on one page. Show all sizes on the same product page and in the same filters, not in a separate corner of the site. Launch new styles in every size on the same day.
  • Open review requests with thanks. Start the post-delivery email by thanking the customer for shopping with you. Then ask what they appreciated about the order, four or five days after it arrives.
MarketLaunch and measure
  • Test the thank-you wording. For four weeks, send half your customers the new email and half your usual one. Compare how many reviews each version brings in and the average stars.
  • Track ratings by size band. Every month, split your ratings into small, middle and extended sizes. If extended sizes trail, read those reviews first and fix what they mention.

Get it by email

New issues every Monday and Thursday, in your inbox. Free, no ads, unsubscribe anytime.

Your address is used only to send Marketing in 3. You will get one email to confirm.

What to expect

  • Gratitude sits with one group. The lift showed up among larger-sized women who feel judged on their weight, not across all shoppers.
  • A small step per customer. In the third study, each extra point of gratitude on the five-point scale went with roughly one third of a star.
  • Everyone sees the stars. Ratings are public, so in the authors' view goodwill from larger-sized customers can help a seller win shoppers of every size.
  • Costs are real. Larger garments use more material. The authors believe the rating benefit outweighs that, but they did not put a number on costs or profit.

Where it does not work

  • Associations, not proof. Nobody can be given a body size at random, so the ties between size, gratitude and ratings are correlations.
  • A scenario, not a purchase. Women reacted to one T-shirt from a made-up store in a short online task, not to a real shopping trip.
  • Women in two countries. Only women living in the UK or the US took part. Other genders, cultures and categories such as shoes or accessories were not covered.
  • Colour is a weak lead. The black T-shirt result did not hold in the third and largest study.
  • Stars and sales move together. The marketplace records cannot tell which one drives the other.

Questions marketers ask

Do plus-size shoppers prefer buying clothes online?

Earlier work says many do, partly to avoid changing rooms, awkward encounters with sales staff and plus-size sections placed at the back of the store. This paper looks at what happens next: larger-sized women who are anxious about weight stigma tend to feel thankful to the online seller, which in turn comes with better ratings for the store (O’Rourke et al., 2025).

Weight stigma: what exactly was measured?

It is the worry of being judged, turned away or treated unfairly by others because of your weight. The team measured it with five statements, each answered on a seven-step scale.

Should online fashion stores push black clothing?

Offer it rather than push it. The colour effect came and went across the studies, and the authors still recommend a wide range of styles and colours.

Do better seller ratings lead to more sales?

They tend to rise together. In marketplace records for almost 1,500 clothing products, higher-rated sellers sold more, but the link was modest and the data cannot settle cause and effect.

Why focus on gratitude rather than plain happiness?

Gratitude carries a wish to give something back to whoever helped you. The authors argue this makes it less self-focused than happiness or enjoyment, and more likely to reward the seller, for instance with a good rating.

Also new at the time

Psychology & Marketing · 2026

Diversity in Femvertising: An Experimental Investigation

Papadopoulou, Hultman, & Oghazi

Ads that set out to empower women are now common, but does a diverse cast make them work better? Across four experiments, more diverse representation improved how people saw the brand and their intention to buy, mainly because the brand seemed more authentic. Political leaning split the response: liberals warmed to diverse ads, while conservatives preferred casts that looked alike. Inclusion lands best when it reads as genuine rather than token, and when you know who is watching.

Journal of Consumer Behaviour · 2026

Alignment of GenAI Modalities With Product Types in Generating Ads: The Mediating Roles of Cognitive Load and Perceived Immersion

Huang & Jiang

Some AI tools work in a single format, while others blend text, images and sound. Drawing on real-world data and two online studies, this paper finds that multimodal AI ads suit experience products because they make people feel immersed, while single-format AI ads suit search products because they are easier to take in, which lifts intentions to buy. The product, more than the novelty of the tool, should decide how rich the AI-made ad needs to be.

Source

O’Rourke, A.-M., Khan, H., Mathmann, F., & Wang, S. (2025). Gratitude’s impact: the positive influence of larger-sized female shoppers on online fashion retailer ratings. European Journal of Marketing, 59(13), 535-569. https://doi.org/10.1108/ejm-01-2024-0003

This brief is written for practitioners from the published article. Open access (CC BY 4.0): free to read at the publisher. Numbers are as reported by the authors; read the article for full methods.

Keep reading

More issues on Retail · UGC

2026 · No. 27 ·

The review keeps working after the sale

People who read bad reviews before listening paid $17.29 to see a show, against $20.45 for people who read none. The review changes the experience, not just the purchase.

2026 · No. 23 ·

Nobody styles a photo of a bad cookie

Judges called 72.3% of the photos in positive Amazon reviews well composed, against 39.7% of those in negative ones. Nobody stages a complaint.

Bruno Schivinski

Bruno Schivinski is Associate Professor of Marketing at Gdańsk University of Technology. He studies how consumers engage with brands in digital and social media.

About Bruno · All Marketing in 3 issues · Subscribe