Skip to main content

Does calling an online community diverse attract more members? What a Marketing Letters study found

Two sign-up flyers for a local food app were identical except for three phrases. Shown to 3,128 adults across six European countries, the one promising a diverse community drew more would-be members, and the keenest planned to do more once inside.

Peschel et al. find that describing an online community as diverse rather than like-minded raised interest in joining by about 30% among 3,128 Europeans.
Date

7 November 2026

Marketing in 3 · 2025 in research · No. 36 · Paper published 5 September 2025

Five young people of different backgrounds sit on a pink zigzag blanket in an autumn park, laughing as they knock orange paper cups together over a guitar, a halved watermelon and a basket of pastries
A community that promises people unlike yourself can look more inviting, not less. Photo: Vitaly Gariev on Unsplash.

The short answer

It made people more interested. When 3,128 adults in six European countries took part in an online test, a flyer inviting them into a local food community drew more interest in joining when it promised members unlike themselves than when it promised like-minded ones. The diversity message did not quieten anyone once inside: people who were keener to join said they would react to, comment on or share more of the community's posts.

Evidence level
  1. One study
  2. Several studies
  3. Meta-analysis

Key takeaways

  • Interest in joining rose from 3.56 to 4.62 out of 7, roughly 30% higher, when the flyer promised a diverse community instead of a like-minded one.
  • Just 3 phrases differed between the two flyers; the offer, the design and the download link stayed exactly the same.
  • People shown the diverse pitch planned about a quarter more actions on a community post: 1.31 against 1.04, out of a possible 4.
  • Location mattered as much as wording: Dutch respondents given the diverse flyer were less keen to join (3.74) than Spanish respondents given the like-minded one (4.42).

What the researchers did

Anne O. Peschel, Lina F. Jacobsen, Marjia Banovic and Klaus G. Grunert of Aarhus University in Denmark, with Ekaterina Salnikova of NEOMA Business School in France, took up a question many brands are asking again. Some large companies are scaling back their diversity and inclusion work, campaigns on the theme have met both praise and anger, and most earlier research looked at how a single minority group responds. This team wanted to know how ordinary consumers react when an online community tells them its members are diverse.

They borrowed a real community. FOXLINK, an online network for local food that was running when the data were collected, links shoppers with farmers, and its recruitment flyer became the test material. One group read that they could connect with a diverse community and a diverse set of farmers, and test product ideas with consumers different from them. The other group read the same flyer with like-minded in place of diverse and similar in place of different.

Each person rated how much they wanted to join, then saw a genuine post from the community, a tip sheet on cutting food waste at home, and said what they would do with it. Last came five statements measuring how open they are to people unlike themselves.

Participants
3,128 adults from a market research panel, in six regions of France, the Czech Republic, Germany, the Netherlands, Poland and Spain
Sampling
Around 500 per region, matching each region's mix of gender, age and education
Community
FOXLINK, a real online network connecting consumers and farmers around local food
What changed
Three phrases on the sign-up flyer: a diverse community, diverse farmers and consumers unlike you, or like-minded versions similar to you
Measured
Interest in joining (1 to 7), planned actions on one community post (0 to 4) and each person's openness to difference

A diverse pitch drew more interest

The diverse flyer won clearly. On the seven-point scale, readers of the like-minded version sat below the midpoint on wanting to join, and readers of the diverse version sat above it. Allowing for where people lived trimmed the gap only a little.

The direction held in every region. The lift was largest in Poland and France and smallest in Spain, where people were already the keenest to sign up whichever version they read.

How much did people notice the change? Not a great deal. Asked how different from them the members seemed, the two groups averaged 4.04 and 3.92 (of a possible 7), a small though statistically reliable gap. That hints, though it was never tested, that a few words on a flyer can change how appealing a community looks before anyone consciously weighs who its members are.

Lift in interest in joining from the diverse flyer, by country (points on a 1 to 7 scale)
Lift in interest in joining from the diverse flyer, by country (points on a 1 to 7 scale)00.511.5All six countries: 1.06 All six countries1.06Poland: 1.21 Poland1.21France: 1.16 France1.16Germany: 1.00 Germany1.00Netherlands: 0.99 Netherlands0.99Czech Republic: 0.99 Czech Republic0.99Spain: 0.55 Spain0.55
Lift in interest in joining from the diverse flyer, by country (points on a 1 to 7 scale)
Group Value ()
All six countries 1.06
Poland 1.21
France 1.16
Germany 1.0
Netherlands 0.99
Czech Republic 0.99
Spain 0.55

Online Appendix B, 3,128 adults: diverse-flyer mean minus like-minded-flyer mean, worked out by us. Country gaps were not tested one by one.

Do diverse communities become less active?

The researchers expected a catch. People tend to warm to groups of others like themselves, so in a mixed community newcomers might sign up and then hold back, unsure of the unwritten rules. Lurking would feel safer than speaking up.

The data said otherwise. Everyone ticked which of four things they would do with the food waste post: react, comment, share it, or share it with a note of their own. Those who had seen the diverse pitch chose a few more of them, and the analysis gave no sign of a hidden drop in activity.

The diversity wording did not lift activity on its own, though. It worked through interest: the keener someone was to join, the more they planned to do. That link was stronger among people high in diversity orientation, a psychologist's term for valuing both what people share and how they differ. Openness did not make anyone respond more to the word diverse itself. It made their interest more likely to turn into action.

Planned actions on a community post, out of 4 (react, comment, share, share with comment)
Planned actions on a community post, out of 4 (react, comment, share, share with comment)01234All six, like-minded flyer: 1.04 All six, like-minded flyer1.04All six, diverse flyer: 1.31 All six, diverse flyer1.31Netherlands, like-minded: 0.61 Netherlands, like-minded0.61Netherlands, diverse: 0.73 Netherlands, diverse0.73Spain, like-minded: 1.45 Spain, like-minded1.45Spain, diverse: 1.63 Spain, diverse1.63
Planned actions on a community post, out of 4 (react, comment, share, share with comment)
Group Value ()
All six, like-minded flyer 1.04
All six, diverse flyer 1.31
Netherlands, like-minded 0.61
Netherlands, diverse 0.73
Spain, like-minded 1.45
Spain, diverse 1.63

Results section and Online Appendix B, 3,128 adults. The Netherlands and Spain had the lowest and highest scores of the six countries.

Purpose still does most of the work

The authors recommend celebrating diversity when presenting an online community, since they found no penalty for it. Diversity campaigns have sparked anger elsewhere, so that reassurance needs a footnote: nobody here was asked whether the message irritated them, which makes the evidence against a backlash indirect.

Their second point matters as much. Because wanting to join drove activity more than anything else, they argue that a recruitment message should also make plain what the community is for and what it values. Diversity widens the door; a clear purpose brings in the people who will actually take part.

Marketing in 3 steps

Ready. Set. Market.

ReadyDecide and prepare
  • Describe who is already inside. List three or four real differences among your current members, such as age, location, background or level of expertise. Use only what you can back up with member data or a short poll.
  • Say what the group is for. Sum up in a single sentence what members get done together, such as swapping recipes or trying new products. Keep it under 20 words so it fits on a banner or a sign-up button.
SetBuild it
  • Swap the 'people like you' line. In your sign-up message, replace phrases such as 'people like you' with 'people with different experiences from yours'. Change only those words and keep the offer, images and button the same.
  • Make the first post easy to answer. Greet new members with a post they can respond to in seconds: a short tip list, a question or a photo prompt. Ask for one small action, such as a reaction or a one-line comment.
MarketLaunch and measure
  • Run both versions side by side. Show the like-minded wording to half your audience and the mixed wording to the rest, for two weeks. Count sign-ups for every 100 people who see each version.
  • Watch the first 30 days. For each new member, count reactions, comments and shares in their first month. Split the results by country or region, because the same message can land very differently from one market to the next.

Get it by email

New issues every Monday and Thursday, in your inbox. Free, no ads, unsubscribe anytime.

Your address is used only to send Marketing in 3. You will get one email to confirm.

What to expect

  • Interest first. The clearest gain was in how many people wanted to join; the diverse version moved the typical reader from lukewarm to mildly keen.
  • A modest knock-on. The extra activity came through that interest and amounted to a fraction of one additional action per person.
  • Bigger returns among the open-minded. People who value difference turned interest into action more readily. Our extrapolation is that the effect will be strongest where an audience already leans that way.
  • Different starting points. The same flyer met a much warmer welcome in some countries than in others, before any wording was changed.

Where it does not work

  • Intentions, not behaviour. Nobody actually joined or posted; people said how interested they were and ticked what they would do.
  • One question for interest. Wanting to join was measured with a single rating, and the authors suggest adding signals such as time spent on the page.
  • One community, one post. A local food network and a food waste tip sheet; brand communities, hobby groups or professional forums may react differently.
  • Openness measured last. Diversity orientation was asked after the flyer, and the diverse group scored slightly higher on it (4.90 against 4.67), so the flyer may have nudged those answers. This is our observation; the paper does not discuss it.
  • Uneven groups. 1,810 people saw the like-minded flyer and 1,318 the diverse one, and no reason is given.
  • Europe only. Six regions were analysed together, with region as a control; audiences elsewhere were not tested.

Questions marketers ask

Does saying an online community is diverse attract more members?

In stated interest, yes. Europeans who read a sign-up flyer promising a diverse community rated their wish to join about a point higher, out of seven, than those promised like-minded members (Peschel et al., 2025). Actual sign-ups were not tracked.

Will members of a diverse community be less active?

Not on this evidence. Those who saw the diverse version planned slightly more reactions, comments and shares on a community post, and no direct dip was linked to the diversity message.

What is diversity orientation?

An attitude that recognises and accepts both the similarities and the differences between people. It was measured here with five short statements, and higher scorers were more likely to convert interest in a community into activity.

Did the diverse message work in every country?

The diverse version came out ahead in all six regions surveyed, from North Brabant in the Netherlands to Valencia in Spain. The size of the lift, and how keen people were to begin with, varied considerably between them.

What should a community sign-up message say?

The authors suggest pairing a clear signal that many kinds of people are welcome with an equally clear statement of the community's purpose and values, so the message reaches people who genuinely care about what the group does.

Also new at the time

Psychology & Marketing · 2025

The Rise of the Deinfluencers: Perceived Similarity and Anticipated Emotions in Advocating Mindful Consumption on Social Media

Tran, Aboulnasr, & Song

Deinfluencers urge followers to skip overpriced, indulgent or useless products and to live more simply and sustainably. In four studies, people felt they shared more attitudes and values with deinfluencers than with conventional influencers. That sense of kinship stirred anticipated pride and guilt, which strengthened intentions to consume mindfully, and those intentions predicted willingness to pay more for sustainably made goods and to engage with the creator's posts; the fourth study tied the chain to actual mindful buying. A creator who tells followers to buy less can still be a good partner for the brand selling the better alternative.

Qualitative Market Research · 2025

Algorithm-shaped norms: how YouTube's comment ranking algorithm influences consumer reactions to social issue campaigns

Feng & Chen

When a brand posts a campaign promoting inclusive gender identity on YouTube, the comments the platform ranks at the top can set the tone for everyone who scrolls down. Interviews with 23 YouTube users point to four ways people conform to those top comments, passive, indirect, direct and active, each with its own degree of agreement and willingness to speak up. Together these reactions help the view that sits at the top become the one that seems to dominate. The first screen of comments under a campaign deserves as much care as the campaign itself.

Source

Peschel, A. O., Jacobsen, L. F., Salnikova, E., Banovic, M., & Grunert, K. G. (2025). The power of diversity in online communities. Marketing Letters, 36(4), 949-962. https://doi.org/10.1007/s11002-025-09792-4

This brief is written for practitioners from the published article. Open access (CC BY 4.0): free to read at the publisher. Numbers are as reported by the authors; read the article for full methods.

Keep reading

More issues on Social media · Creative

2026 · No. 41 ·

Matching looks suit posts, a mix suits stories

Boluki et al. studied 1,812 Instagram posts and stories from 182 influencer campaigns: matching looks suit posts, while stories do better with a mix.

2026 · No. 40 ·

Trend videos with a twist beat close copies

An analysis of 85,000 TikTok dance videos plus three experiments finds that putting your own spin on a trend earns more likes than copying it closely.

Bruno Schivinski

Bruno Schivinski is Associate Professor of Marketing at Gdańsk University of Technology. He studies how consumers engage with brands in digital and social media.

About Bruno · All Marketing in 3 issues · Subscribe