Do AR try-on tools build stronger brand bonds? What a Journal of Consumer Behaviour study found
Watching sneakers appear on the feet through an AR try-on, rather than on a product page, helped women picture wearing them, feel more open to change and connect more with a sportswear brand. With Gucci, the shoes became easier to picture but the bond did not grow, and picturing did less for the sense of self when the virtual look felt far from the real one.
Kim & Im find an AR sneaker try-on made women see themselves as more changeable and tied them closer to a sportswear brand, but not reliably to Gucci.
Marketing in 3 · 2023 in research · No. 52 · Paper published 10 December 2023
Seeing a new look on yourself is much of the appeal of any try-on, real or virtual. Photo: Bruno Dias on Unsplash.
The short answer
For an everyday brand, yes. In an online experiment, 116 US women in their 20s and 30s watched a sneaker try-on filmed from the shopper's point of view, either through an AR app or on a mobile website. The AR version made the sportswear brand feel closer to their own identity, by helping them picture wearing the shoes and feel that their self-image could change. With Gucci sneakers, that closer bond did not reliably appear.
Evidence level
★★★One study
★★★Several studies
★★★Meta-analysis
Key takeaways
After the AR try-on video, ease of picturing oneself in the sneakers averaged 5.84 out of 7. The mobile website video produced 4.98.
Seen through AR, the sportswear sneakers lifted agreement that one's self-image can change from 4.35 to 5.01.
The sense that the sportswear brand reflects who you are rose to 5.29 with AR, from 4.66 on the website, measured the same way.
With Gucci sneakers, AR still made the shoes easier to picture (5.65 against 5.13), but brand connection (4.93 against 4.37) did not differ reliably.
What the researchers did
Terry Haekyung Kim and Hyunjoo Im, retail and consumer researchers from the University of Minnesota, wanted to
pin down what sets an AR try-on apart from a product page. With AR, a shopper can swap one item for the next in a
split second and see each one on their own body. Earlier work had shown that wearing a piece of clothing can change how people describe themselves. The team
asked whether watching your appearance change quickly, item after item, also changes how fixed you believe you are.
Psychologists call that belief the malleability of the self: the sense that your self-image, and the kind of person
you are, can change. The authors expected AR to strengthen it by making the experience more vivid, which they
measured as imagery, meaning how easily people could picture themselves wearing the product. A more flexible self
should in turn find more points of contact with a brand. That is self-brand connection, the degree to which a brand
has become part of how someone sees themselves.
They ran two online experiments with American women aged 20 to 39, sourced via Amazon Mechanical Turk. Each woman
watched one short video, filmed from a first-person angle, showing either an AR app or a mobile website, while
imagining she was shopping for sneakers. The first experiment used a mass-market sportswear brand, the second Gucci.
Sneakers were chosen so that no faces had to appear on screen.
Participants
US women between 20 and 39 years old, recruited online: 116 in the first experiment, 110 in the second (53 AR, 57 website)
Products
Five pairs of women's sneakers from a sportswear brand, shown through the Wanna Kicks try-on app; then six pairs of Gucci sneakers, shown through Gucci's own AR app
What changed
Whether the video showed the sneakers in an AR try-on app or on the brand's mobile web pages, with the same items in both versions
Measured
Imagery, malleability of the self, self-brand connection and intention to revisit the website, on 1 to 7 agreement scales; the second experiment added virtual self-discrepancy
Analysis
Analysis of variance, then serial and moderated serial mediation (PROCESS Models 6 and 91, 5,000 resamples)
Sportswear: AR strengthened the brand link
With the sportswear sneakers, the AR group came out ahead on all three measures. Education and household income
were similar across the groups, and controlling for both left the results unchanged.
The more telling result is the route. A serial mediation test traced a chain from AR to stronger imagery, from
imagery to a more malleable sense of self, and from there to self-brand connection. With that chain in the model,
AR itself added nothing further to the brand link. The authors classify this as full mediation. Imagery was also
tied to self-brand connection by itself, without passing through malleability. The path coefficients printed in the model
figure are .74 from imagery to malleability, .49 from malleability to the brand link and .43 for that direct route.
The stronger a woman's connection to the brand, the higher her stated intention to visit the website again
(β = .70).
Sportswear sneakers: scores after the AR and website videos (1 to 7 scale)
Sportswear sneakers: scores after the AR and website videos (1 to 7 scale)
Group
Value ()
Picturing the shoes, website
4.98
Picturing the shoes, AR
5.84
Self-image can change, website
4.35
Self-image can change, AR
5.01
Brand connection, website
4.66
Brand connection, AR
5.29
Experiment 1, 116 US women on Amazon Mechanical Turk, means reported in the text. All three differences were significant (p < .05 or lower).
Gucci: easier to picture, but no closer bond
The second experiment repeated the design with six Gucci sneakers and Gucci's own app and web pages. AR again made
it easier to picture wearing the shoes. This time beliefs about the self barely moved: 4.99 with AR against 4.96 with
the website.
To see why, the team added a measure called virtual self-discrepancy: how far the look on screen felt from the
person's actual self. One item read "I felt the appearance was different from my actual self". The higher this
score, the weaker the link from imagery to malleability. In unstandardised terms, the effect was .86 one standard
deviation below the average discrepancy, .61 at the average and .35 one standard deviation above it. The full chain
from AR to brand connection held at low and average levels of discrepancy and was not significant at high levels.
Brand connection again predicted intention to return to the website (β = .76).
Gucci sneakers: scores after the AR and website videos (1 to 7 scale)
Gucci sneakers: scores after the AR and website videos (1 to 7 scale)
Group
Value ()
Picturing the shoes, website
5.13
Picturing the shoes, AR
5.65
Self-image can change, website
4.96
Self-image can change, AR
4.99
Brand connection, website
4.37
Brand connection, AR
4.93
Experiment 2, 110 US women (53 AR, 57 website), means reported in the text. Only the difference in picturing the shoes was significant.
Why the brand may matter
Self-discrepancy theory is the authors' explanation. A modest distance between who you are and an image of
yourself lets you take that image on board. A very large distance makes the contrast stand out, and the
image is rejected. Luxury labels tend to stand for an ideal self rather than the everyday one. They add that
typical luxury customers are around 43 years old with an average income of $136,000. Their participants
averaged 31.52 and 30.84 years in the two experiments, and more than half had incomes between $20,000 and $65,000.
One caution is our own reading of the design. Brand was not varied inside a single experiment, and the two
experiments also differed in app, website and number of items. The contrast between sportswear and Gucci therefore
reflects more than the brand. The discrepancy measure, collected within the Gucci experiment, is the more direct
evidence for the authors' explanation.
The authors' advice
Adding AR try-on to online stores is their first recommendation, on the argument that shoppers who see themselves
as more adaptable will find more brands that fit them. They see uses for new brands that want to attract a
competitor's customers, for brand extensions into new product lines and for retailers who want shoppers to try their own labels.
Because intention to revisit rose with brand connection, they also present AR as a route to loyalty.
Their advice differs by brand. Brands that are moderately familiar to most consumers, which they call masstige, can
use AR actively. Brands with more distinctive characteristics should work on reducing the distance between the real and
the virtual self, for instance by offering the try-on mainly to core customers and reaching others through tools
such as product customisation. For shoppers who do feel that distance, the authors suggest a try-on that is as
vivid and interactive as possible, since imagery still fed brand connection directly. These are recommendations;
neither experiment tested them.
Marketing in 3 steps
Ready. Set. Market.
1
ReadyDecide and prepare
Choose the items to put in try-on first. Pick 10 to 20 products that people judge on their own body, such as shoes, glasses, hats or lipstick shades. Start with the lines most of your shoppers already feel at home with.
Ask how far each line feels from your shoppers. Show 20 customers photos of your best sellers and ask one question for each: can you picture yourself wearing this? Mark every line where most say no as a distant line.
2
SetBuild it
Let people swap in one tap. Load at least six options into each try-on session and let shoppers switch between them with a single tap or swipe. Each new item should appear on the shopper in under a second.
Keep the shopper in the frame. Set the default view to show the item on the shopper's own body, as they would see it looking down or in a mirror. Put the model photos one tap away rather than first.
3
MarketLaunch and measure
Point distant lines at regular buyers first. For the distant lines, show the try-on button first to people who have bought from that line before. Give everyone else another way in, such as a colour or fit customiser.
Track return visits for 30 days. Count the try-on users who return to your site within 30 days and set that against other visitors. Ask one question after each try-on, "This brand suits me", scored 1 to 7, and follow it month by month.
Found this useful?
Marketing in 3 is free and ad-free, with new issues every Monday and Thursday. A coffee keeps it that way.
Vividness comes first. Any gain in brand connection ran through how easily people pictured themselves in the product, so, in our reading, a try-on that looks flat or slow is unlikely to help.
Premium lines need a separate plan. For a label that feels out of reach, AR may make the product easier to imagine without making shoppers feel the brand fits them.
Return visits are a first signal. Brand connection and plans to revisit moved closely together in both experiments; purchases were not measured, so sales gains are an assumption.
One session, short effects. People saw five or six items in one short video. Whether longer or repeated use changes how people see themselves more lastingly is, as the authors say, still open.
Where it does not work
Videos, not hands-on use. Participants watched a pre-recorded session, seen as the shopper would see it; none used an AR app on their own body.
Women only, in one age band. Everyone was a US woman aged 20 to 39 recruited online; men, older shoppers and other countries were not tested.
One product type. Both experiments used sneakers. The authors note that make-up try-ons, which show the face, may work differently.
Two brands, two set-ups. Brand changed between experiments along with the app, the website and the number of items, so the sportswear and Gucci results are not a controlled comparison.
Stated intentions. Revisiting the website was asked about, not tracked, and no purchases were recorded.
Questions marketers ask
Does an AR try-on build brand loyalty?
Indirectly, for an everyday brand. Women shown sneakers through AR felt a sportswear brand reflected who they are more than women who saw the same pairs on a mobile website, and those who felt that bond also reported more intention to revisit the site (Kim & Im, 2024). With Gucci, the bond did not reliably rise.
What does malleability of the self mean?
It describes how changeable people believe they are: whether their self-image and character can shift or stay fixed. Some people hold this view more firmly than others, and it can grow for a while when a situation brings different sides of a person to mind. Participants rated items like 'My self-image is something about me that I can change'.
Why did AR try-on not help the luxury brand?
The authors point to virtual self-discrepancy, the feeling that the person on screen does not match the real you. Among women who felt that strongly, picturing the Gucci sneakers did much less to make them feel changeable, and the indirect path linking AR with brand connection was not significant.
What is self-brand connection?
How far someone has made a brand part of how they see themselves. Five items captured it, among them 'This brand suits me well' and 'This brand can reflect who I am', and women marked how far they agreed with each.
Would AR mirrors in physical stores work the same way?
The authors think in-store AR mirrors or fitting rooms may produce a similar effect. Both experiments took place online, though, so that remains untested.
Brands now hire computer-generated influencers, and this paper asks whether making them look more human helps. In two between-subjects experiments with 178 and 162 participants, the more humanlike versions were judged more authentic, which led to warmer attitudes to the ad and stronger purchase intentions. Feeling similar to the influencer, or wanting to be like it, explained the effect only in the study that used a hedonic product. A brand designing its own virtual face may find realism worth the extra rendering budget.
Retailers that join up their channels want customers to keep coming back. A survey of 292 omnichannel customers separated three kinds of integration, informational, transactional and relational, and traced their effect on patronage through flow, the absorbed state people reach when an experience runs smoothly. Transactional and relational integration raised patronage through flow, and shared values between retailer and customer strengthened the effects of informational and relational integration on flow. Linking channels seems to work best for shoppers who already feel the retailer stands for what they do.
Source
Kim, T. H., & Im, H. (2024). Can augmented reality impact your self-perceptions? The malleability of the self and brand relationships in augmented reality try-on services. Journal of Consumer Behaviour, 23(4), 1623-1637. https://doi.org/10.1002/cb.2296
This brief is written for practitioners from the published article. Open access (CC BY 4.0): free to read at the publisher. Numbers are as reported by the authors; read the article for full methods.
Facebook reported a return of 7.47 on retargeting. A field experiment across 210 markets found the retargeting budget could be cut to zero without losing a single order.
Herhausen et al. find in-store screen ads made shoppers 8.1% likelier to buy the advertised product, across 237 campaigns in ten European supermarkets.
Zenetti and Pauwels find 17 shoppers research on a retail site and buy elsewhere for every 10 who buy there, and display and video ads tilt furthest off-site.
Bruno Schivinski is Associate Professor of Marketing at Gdańsk University of Technology. He studies how consumers engage with brands in digital and social media.