Do ads that cheer people on after a breakup get more clicks than ads about loved ones? What a Psychology & Marketing study found
Ads love to show people enjoying life with their loved ones. In two experiments with US adults, a mock Facebook post that nudged people past a breakup drew more clicks, because readers felt the brand was there for them.
Tan et al. find a reassuring breakup line in a mock Facebook ad nearly doubled clicks for more information over a loved-ones line, in two US tests.
Marketing in 3 · 2023 in research · No. 2 · Paper published 2 February 2023
An ad that meets someone after a breakup can make a brand feel like company. Photo: Tony Lam Hoang on Unsplash.
The short answer
In two online experiments, yes. People who saw a mock Facebook ad telling them it was fine to move on after a breakup clicked through for more information almost twice as often as people who saw the same ad built around loved ones. The breakup line made the brand feel more supportive. In the second test, that extra support showed up only among people who believe partners are either meant to be or not.
Evidence level
★★★One study
★★★Several studies
★★★Meta-analysis
Key takeaways
The cookie ad drew clicks from 23.1% of viewers when it reassured them after a breakup, against 12.5% when it invited them to enjoy the cookies with loved ones.
The travel ad repeated the pattern, 21.6% against 11.2%, so the gain carried over from a snack to a holiday.
On the support measure, which runs from 1 to 7, the brand gained roughly half a point after the breakup version in each test, and that gain carried the extra clicks.
None of the 408 participants was asked whether they had been through a breakup, so the gain came from a general audience, not from people known to be newly single.
What the researchers did
Ser Zian Tan of Sunway University in Malaysia,
Argho Bandyopadhyay of RMIT University in Melbourne and
Felix Septianto of the University of Queensland in Brisbane
looked at one of advertising's oldest habits. Campaigns for wine, restaurants, shampoo and holidays often show people
enjoying themselves with a partner, friends or family. Earlier work found that such reminders can backfire with
people who have lost the relationship on show.
A few brands have flipped the idea and talk to people after a split instead, offering a push to move on. The question
here was simple: when the goal is a click, does that kind of encouragement beat a standard nod to loved ones?
Each participant saw one version of a mock Facebook sponsored post, followed by a link to further reading on the same
topic, and the researchers recorded who clicked it. The two versions shared the picture, the brand and the layout.
Only the opening line changed.
Participants
208 US adults in the first experiment and 200 in the second, all recruited on Prolific
Ads
Mock Facebook posts for a cookie brand, then for a travel brand, each in two versions
Outcome
Whether people clicked a link to an article on the best cookies in the US or the best places to travel
Measured
How far the brand seemed a source of support (five statements); belief that relationships are destined (eleven statements, second experiment only)
Checks
People noticed the breakup theme: about 5.4 to 5.6 out of seven for breakup posts, under 1.4 for the rest
Two ads, one line apart
The cookie post either invited people to enjoy a bite with their loved ones, or told them it was okay, the breakup
was mutual, and they could enjoy a bite anyway. The travel post either said it was time to travel again with loved
ones, or that it was time to move on from a breakup and travel again.
In both experiments the breakup line won more clicks, and by a similar margin of about ten extra people in every
hundred. A snack and a trip are very different purchases, which makes the repeat more convincing than a single test
would be.
Share of people who clicked for more information, by opening line (%)
Share of people who clicked for more information, by opening line (%)
Group
Value (%)
Cookies: loved ones
12.5
Cookies: it's okay after a breakup
23.1
Travel: loved ones
11.2
Travel: move on from a breakup
21.6
Study 1 (cookies, 208 US adults: 13 of 104 against 24 of 104) and Study 2 (travel, 200 US adults: 11 of 98 against 22 of 102).
Why the breakup line worked
The explanation the authors put forward is social support. People tend to treat brands a little like people, and
after a loss they look for someone who understands. An ad that speaks to that moment can make a brand seem to be
on the reader's side.
To check, participants rated statements such as whether the brand was around when they were in need, whether it
tried to help and whether it cared about their feelings. The breakup versions scored higher both times.
Mediation tests then traced the click gain through that sense of support. The indirect route was significant in each
experiment (0.18 and 0.16, with 95% ranges that stayed above zero), and once support entered the model, the direct
link from the message to clicks no longer reached significance. Put simply, the line worked because it made the
brand feel supportive.
One caveat, which is ours and not the authors': even with the breakup line, average support stayed
below 4, the halfway mark. The brand got warmer, but on average people still did not see it as a confidant.
How supportive the brand seemed, by opening line (1 to 7 scale)
How supportive the brand seemed, by opening line (1 to 7 scale)
Group
Value ()
Cookies: loved ones
3.2
Cookies: breakup
3.7
Travel: loved ones
2.95
Travel: breakup
3.4
Study 1 (208 US adults) and Study 2 (200 US adults): mean agreement with five statements about the brand's support. Both gaps significant (p = 0.030 and 0.032).
Who felt the support: believers in fate
The second experiment also measured destiny beliefs, a lay theory about love. People who hold them strongly agree
with statements such as "potential relationship partners are either compatible or they are not" and read early
trouble as a sign of a poor match. The opposite outlook, that relationships grow through effort, was not measured.
The authors expected destiny believers to take a breakup as proof that it was never meant to be, leaving them ready
to move on and open to support. That is the pattern that appeared. Among people high in destiny belief, the breakup
ad clearly raised felt support (B = 0.50, p = 0.001). Among people low in it, the gap was negligible and not
significant (B = -0.03, p = 0.855).
The knock-on effect on clicks split the same way: a significant indirect effect for strong believers (0.35, range
0.11 to 0.74) and none for weak ones (-0.02, range -0.25 to 0.21). How the authors split high from low belief is not
reported.
Where the authors draw the line
The authors accept that raising breakups in ads poses ethical questions, since negative emotional appeals such as
fear, shame or guilt are known to backfire. Their defence is that these posts did more than remind people of a lost
relationship: they offered encouragement. Even so, they urge marketers to think about who will see a campaign, and
about people's relationship status, before using relationship words or images.
For placement, they suggest pairing a breakup line with reassurance in travel ads run around travel programmes,
when viewers may feel ready for a fresh start and book a trip. This went untested, and the experiments say nothing
about timing.
Marketing in 3 steps
Ready. Set. Market.
1
ReadyDecide and prepare
Find your fresh-start moment. List the ways your product helps someone start over after a hard patch: a trip, a treat, a new look, a night out with friends. If you cannot name two that feel natural, drop the idea and keep your usual message.
Rule out the raw spots. Before drafting, list where the ad could land badly, such as next to wedding, baby or anniversary content. Exclude those placements in your ad settings, along with any audience built around bereavement or divorce.
2
SetBuild it
Write one line of encouragement. Open the post with one short sentence telling the reader it is fine to move on, then tie it to your product, for example: "It's okay. Time for something new." Never mention an ex, never assign blame and never poke fun at being single.
Make the brand sound like a friend. Add one line that puts the brand on the reader's side, such as an offer to help plan the trip or pick the treat. Read the whole post aloud. Would a good friend send it? If not, rewrite it until the sales tone is gone.
3
MarketLaunch and measure
Test it against your usual ad. Split one audience at random into two equal halves. Show one half the fresh-start version and the other half your usual post about sharing with loved ones. Give both the same budget, image and link, and run them for at least 14 days.
Count clicks and complaints. Work out how many clicks each version earned per 1,000 viewers. Check comments, hides and negative reactions every day. If the fresh-start post draws more than a handful of upset replies in a week, pause it and soften the wording.
Found this useful?
Marketing in 3 is free and ad-free, with new issues every Monday and Thursday. A coffee keeps it that way.
A cheap test. Only the opening sentence changed between versions, so trying this costs one extra line of copy and a split audience.
Clicks, not sales. The tests tracked whether people went on to read more, so any effect on buying or loyalty remains open.
Part of the audience may shrug. On this evidence, people who see love as fate respond and the rest barely move, so the average lift hides an uneven mix.
Some viewers may object. A breakup is personal. Our reading is that some people will find any mention intrusive whatever the tone, so plan how you will reply to upset comments.
Where it does not work
Survey clicks, not live ads. People judged ad concepts inside an online survey, then chose whether to open a link to an editorial article rather than the brand's own site. Real feeds, with scrolling and competing posts, were not tested.
Narrow margins. Both click gaps passed the usual significance test only just (p = 0.046 and 0.049), with roughly 100 people per version, so the true size of the lift is uncertain.
Love lives unknown. Nobody was asked about a recent breakup. The authors think the effect may be stronger among people going through one, which remains untested.
One gentle kind of breakup. The posts framed the split as mutual or as time to move on. Bitter breakups, and heavier losses such as a death or a painful divorce, were outside the tests.
Two categories, one country. Cookies and travel only, with US panel members, and the data are not shared.
Questions marketers ask
Do breakup-themed ads work?
In two online experiments they beat ads built around loved ones. A mock Facebook post encouraging people to leave a breakup behind led more of them to click for further information (Tan et al., 2023).
Why would a breakup message make people click?
Because it can make the brand feel supportive. People often treat brands as if they were human, and someone getting over a loss seeks understanding. When an ad offers encouragement at that moment, people rate the brand as more caring, and that feeling is what drove the extra clicks.
What are destiny beliefs about relationships?
A lay theory that partners are either right for each other from the start or not, so early problems signal a poor match. It was measured with eleven agree-or-disagree statements, and only people who held it strongly felt more supported by the breakup ad.
Is it ethical to mention breakups in advertising?
The authors take the concern seriously. They argue that encouragement after a breakup differs from simply reminding people of what they lost, but they still ask marketers to consider the audience and its relationship status before using such lines.
Can relationship reminders in ads backfire?
Yes. Earlier research found that images of happy couples, friends or families can put off people who no longer have that relationship. Moving from celebrating a relationship to backing someone after one ends is the alternative tested here.
Saying a restaurant "is great" rather than "was great" can make an opinion more persuasive. Language analysis of more than 500,000 online reviews found that reviews written more in the present tense were rated more helpful, and experiments showed the switch makes the writer sound more certain. Eight studies in the field and the lab support the pattern. A tense swap in a testimonial costs nothing to try.
On peer-to-peer platforms, providers review their customers too. Across a pilot and seven studies, five of them preregistered, a negative review from a provider led consumers to speak badly of the platform itself, because they felt the platform had betrayed them. Keeping such reviews private rather than public, or letting consumers respond, retaliate or dispute them, softened the reaction. When customers get rated, the platform's review policy shapes what they say about it.
Source
Tan, S. Z., Bandyopadhyay, A., & Septianto, F. (2023). Relationship (breakup) reminders drive online advertising effectiveness. Psychology & Marketing, 40(6), 1152-1161. https://doi.org/10.1002/mar.21796
This brief is written for practitioners from the published article. Open access (CC BY 4.0): free to read at the publisher. Numbers are as reported by the authors; read the article for full methods.
Zagni et al. read 730 player posts and ran 12 interviews: in-game ads were welcomed when they fit the game world or helped play, resented when they stopped it.
Milano et al. tested 98 advertising professionals: generative AI doubled the number of tagline ideas, but only after prompt training, and quality stayed flat.
Bruno Schivinski is Associate Professor of Marketing at Gdańsk University of Technology. He studies how consumers engage with brands in digital and social media.