Should a content teaser stop mid-sentence? What a Psychology & Marketing study found
News sites and blogs often cut a preview off halfway through a sentence to pull readers in. Five experiments show the trick works when the rest is free, and backfires when readers have to pay to find out how the sentence ends.
Mandler et al. find teasers cut off mid-sentence cost paid sales: 18% of students bought an article after one, against 33% after a teaser that finished.
Marketing in 3 · 2024 in research · No. 30 · Paper published 7 August 2024
A glimpse through the gap pulls people in, until they see a price on the door. Photo: Dima Pechurin on Unsplash.
The short answer
Only if the rest is free. In five experiments, a preview that broke off partway through a sentence made people keener to read or watch free content, but less willing to pay when a paywall came next. With a price attached, the cut-off ending looked like a sales trick rather than a hook. For paid content, a teaser that ends on a complete sentence did better.
Evidence level
★★★One study
★★★Several studies
★★★Meta-analysis
Key takeaways
With real vouchers to spend, 18.3% of students bought a €0.49 article after a teaser that broke off mid-sentence, against 33.3% after a teaser that ended cleanly.
In the final experiment, the cut-off ending lifted curiosity about a free travel article (3.88 against 3.49, scored 1 to 7), but not about a paid one, where it sat at 2.79 with a clean ending and 2.58 without.
A camera reading 56 students' faces found their expressions turned about twice as negative in the five seconds after an unfinished teaser and a payment notice, while a finished teaser left them unchanged.
Testing 400 adults online, the team found that cutting off the preview of a free travel article lifted intentions to read on from 4.01 to 4.69 out of 7.
What the researchers did
Timo Mandler of TBS Business School in Toulouse, Gerrit P. Cziehso of ALDI Data & Analytics Services in Germany,
Tobias Schaefers of Copenhagen Business School and Hochschule Bielefeld, Ann-Kristin Kupfer of the Karlsruhe Institute
of Technology and Alexander Mafael of the Stockholm School of Economics looked at a small choice publishers make every
day. A preview of an article or a video can stop where a sentence ends. Or it can stop just after a new sentence
begins, leaving the reader hanging. Both styles are common on news sites and blogging platforms, sometimes for the very
same story.
Theory points both ways. A gap in what you know makes you curious, and curious people want to close it. But a gap you
can only close by paying might look less like a hook and more like a trap.
The team began with a written pre-test, asking students to describe how a cut-off preview made them feel. They then ran
five experiments. The first two took place in a lab, with a news article people had to pay for. The other three set
free and paid versions side by side, first with text, then with video, and finally with a broader group of adults in
a study registered before it ran.
Pre-test
45 students wrote about a cut-off news preview, with or without a charge to read on
Experiments
Two in a lab with students (143 and 56), two online with students (279 and 179), one online with 400 adults on Prolific
Content
Previews of news articles on job prospects, a spring break party and summer travel, plus a short video on making money with Bitcoin
The cut-off
Unfinished versions added the opening words of one more sentence, such as "It soon became obvious that ..."
The price
€0.49 to unlock the rest, wherever a price was named
Measured
Real purchases, facial expressions, plans to buy or read, curiosity, and how plainly people felt they were being persuaded
Checks
Sample sizes worked out in advance; the final study registered on AsPredicted
What happened when the rest cost money
The first experiment put a real choice on the table. Each student got two vouchers worth €0.50 each. After reading a
teaser about job prospects in business, they could spend one voucher on the full article, or swap both for a chocolate
bar, a lollipop or a pencil. The groups differed in one thing only: whether the teaser trailed off with "In addition, it
has been shown that ..." or ended with a complete sentence. The trailing version sold markedly fewer articles.
The second experiment watched faces rather than wallets. A webcam and emotion-reading software followed students as
they read the same teaser and then reached the payment notice. During the opening lines the two groups looked much
alike. After a clean ending their expressions held steady. After the cut-off ending they turned clearly more negative,
just as the reader learned there was a charge to see the rest.
When the rest was free, the cut-off helped
The third experiment added the comparison that matters most. Students read a short, light piece about students
celebrating spring break and were told three quarters of it was missing. Some learned they could read on for free;
others that they would have to pay. On free content, the unfinished ending left people keener to keep reading. On
paid content, it put them off buying.
The fourth experiment swapped text for video. A clip promising tips on earning money from Bitcoin either broke off as
the voice said "Bitcoin is ..." or finished its thought. With the cut-off, viewing intentions for the free version
rose from 4.05 to 4.78 out of 7. On the paid side buying intentions dipped again, but this time the gap was too
small to rule out chance with the usual confidence.
Intentions to buy or read the full article, by teaser ending and access (1 to 7 scale)
Intentions to buy or read the full article, by teaser ending and access (1 to 7 scale)
Group
Value ()
Paid, finished teaser
1.4
Paid, unfinished teaser
1.13
Free, finished teaser
3.3
Free, unfinished teaser
4.27
Study 3a, online experiment with 279 students, spring break article. The cut-off ending lowered buying intentions and raised reading intentions; both differences were significant.
Why a price changes how the gap feels
The final experiment, with adults screened for an interest in travel, looked at what went on in people's heads. Two
forces were at work. Curiosity rose with the cut-off ending, but only where the article was free. On paid content
curiosity stayed low whatever the ending. What moved instead was the sense that the publisher was plainly trying to
persuade them, which climbed when an unfinished teaser met a price.
Tests of the two routes matched that picture. For free content the extra reading ran through curiosity. For paid
content the only route that registered ran through the feeling of being worked on, and it pointed downwards. One detail is worth knowing: in this experiment, buying
intentions for the paid article were low and barely differed between the two endings. The lost sales show most
clearly in the lab purchase test.
Free readers also rated the teaser as a fairly clear attempt to persuade, whichever ending they got. They simply did not hold it
against the publisher. Being nudged towards something you can have at once feels very different from being nudged
towards the till.
How plainly the publisher seemed to be persuading readers (1 to 7 scale)
How plainly the publisher seemed to be persuading readers (1 to 7 scale)
Group
Value ()
Paid, finished teaser
3.62
Paid, unfinished teaser
4.54
Free, finished teaser
4.22
Free, unfinished teaser
4.41
Study 4, preregistered online experiment with 400 adults, summer travel article. Only the rise for paid content was significant.
Where each ending belongs
The practical split is clear. If the click leads to something free, such as an article paid for by advertising, a
preview that stops mid-sentence is the better choice. The authors mention short news snippets in search results
that send readers on to a publisher's site, and travel reviews that open in full on a click. If the click leads to a
paywall, the preview that ends on a full stop wins.
Publishers who still want the cut-off style on paid content get two suggestions, neither tested here: say clearly
and early that the piece is paid, and explain why the price is there. Both aim to make the charge feel open and
fair. The authors also urge A/B tests of teaser styles on each audience, since the best length and wording
will vary from one readership to the next.
Marketing in 3 steps
Ready. Set. Market.
1
ReadyDecide and prepare
List every preview you publish. Go through your homepage, newsletter, app and social posts. Write down each place where readers see the first lines of a piece, and mark whether the click leads to free content or to a paywall.
Set one ending rule for each kind. For anything free, plan previews that stop a few words into a new sentence. For anything behind a paywall, plan previews that stop at a full stop. Add both rules to your style guide.
2
SetBuild it
Finish paid previews cleanly. Cut each paid preview at the end of a sentence. Pick a sentence that tells the reader what the rest will give them, such as the three tips or the final answer.
Break free previews at a promising point. End each free preview three to five words into a sentence that sets up a payoff, such as "The second reason is ...". Never cut in the middle of a name or a figure.
3
MarketLaunch and measure
Show the price before the preview. On paid pieces, put a clear subscriber label next to the headline, above the first line. Add one short line on what the payment supports, so the paywall never comes as a surprise.
Compare both endings for two weeks. Show half your visitors the clean ending and half the cut-off one. After two weeks, count new subscribers from paid pieces and reads of free ones. Scan replies and comments for words like trick or clickbait.
Found this useful?
Marketing in 3 is free and ad-free, with new issues every Monday and Thursday. A coffee keeps it that way.
The free-content gain is the steady part. A cut-off ending raised reading or viewing intentions for free content in every experiment that offered it.
Paying stays a hard sell. Even with the better ending, willingness to pay for a single article or video stayed low, under 3 out of 7, in every online test. A good teaser trims losses; it does not create keen buyers.
Read the lab figure as a direction. The authors warn against leaning on the size of the drop in purchases, since it comes from one lab test. The direction is what held up across their work.
More traffic on free pieces. Cut-off previews should send more readers through to free content, which can feed advertising income. Intentions to read were measured; ad revenue was not.
Where it does not work
Mostly students. Four of the five experiments used university students; only the last drew on a wider panel of adults.
A tiny price for a single piece. The charge was under a euro. Subscriptions and larger sums were not tested.
Mostly stated intentions. One experiment recorded real purchases. Everywhere else, people rated their own plans.
Excerpts only. Every teaser was the opening of the piece itself, seen just before the choice to read on. Recut summaries, or previews seen days before buying, may behave differently.
One sitting, one teaser. Each person met a single preview once. Regular readers who know how a site's previews work may react in other ways.
Questions marketers ask
Do teasers that stop mid-sentence get more clicks?
On free content, yes. A preview that breaks off just as a new sentence starts made people more curious and readier to read or watch the rest, provided nothing stood between them and it (Mandler et al., 2024).
Why would a cliffhanger teaser hurt sales of paid content?
The price changes what the gap means. Once people see they must pay to finish the sentence, the cut-off looks deliberate, and they resist by not buying. Their curiosity about the rest does not grow enough to make up for it.
What is persuasion knowledge?
Everything people have learned about how sellers try to influence them. When a tactic looks too obvious, that knowledge kicks in: people start asking what the seller is after and become harder to win over.
Does this apply to video previews as well as text?
It held for a short video that stopped as the speaker began a new sentence, as well as for text previews of news articles. Film trailers, which recut scenes into a new story, were not tested, and the authors do not extend the results to them.
How should a paywalled publisher write its previews?
End them on a full stop. The clean ending sold more in the lab and drew fewer negative reactions, while the cut-off ending only helped where readers could carry on for free.
Charities often ask donors to post about their gift, either about themselves ("I just gave") or about the cause. Donors turned out to be more willing to share posts about the charity than about their own donation, because talking about yourself feels less selfless and so seems less likely to move friends. Posts about the charity also brought in more new donors. When you hand supporters a ready-made post, the cause should be the hero, not the giver.
A digital comics platform let readers unlock the next episode of chosen series for free if they waited a set time, or pay to read it straight away. Viewing data showed the offer raised paid reading of those series, from impatient readers and from readers who got far enough to reach the paid-only episodes at the end. A model-picked set of promoted comics would have earned about 18% more than the platform's own picks. Slowing people down, rather than rushing them, can be the promotion.
Source
Mandler, T., Cziehso, G. P., Schaefers, T., Kupfer, A.-K., & Mafael, A. (2024). This article is… Consumer reactions to unfinished teasers for digital content. Psychology & Marketing, 41(12), 2977-2991. https://doi.org/10.1002/mar.22098
This brief is written for practitioners from the published article. Open access (CC BY-NC 4.0): free to read at the publisher. Numbers are as reported by the authors; read the article for full methods.
Zagni et al. read 730 player posts and ran 12 interviews: in-game ads were welcomed when they fit the game world or helped play, resented when they stopped it.
Milano et al. tested 98 advertising professionals: generative AI doubled the number of tagline ideas, but only after prompt training, and quality stayed flat.
Bruno Schivinski is Associate Professor of Marketing at Gdańsk University of Technology. He studies how consumers engage with brands in digital and social media.